New York Mutuals 1875 Roster

Wins: 30   Losses: 38   Rank: 6

Billy Barnie
Eddie Booth
Count Gedney
Joe Gerhardt
Jimmy Hallinan
John Hatfield
Nat Hicks
Dick Higham
Jim Holdsworth
Bobby Mathews
Pat McGee
Alfred Metcalfe
Candy Nelson
Nealy Phelps
Joe Start